In theory, Mark DeRosa will be the most nervous observer when Mexico and Italy play the final game in Pool B of the World Baseball Classic Wednesday, March 11 in Houston, with the fate of Team USA in the balance.
In reality, his gaffe on national television can’t totally be undone with the result of a ballgame.
In what will go down as one of the more significant managerial oversights in the middle of a championship, DeRosa went on his own network with friendly hosts and claimed that the Americans ‒ sitting at 3-0 and apparently indomitable ‒ were already through to the quarterfinals.
Alas, the buzz of their postgame celebration after vanquishing Mexico had hardly worn off when DeRosa joined MLB Network for the sort of interview he’d conducted hundreds of times. But an Italian team with legit big league power loomed in their final game.
And the Americans got crushed. And, in fact, suddenly have their own fate out of their hands.
Though the odds remain in their favor, a viable scenario ‒ Mexico beating Italy while scoring four or fewer runs ‒ exists to send Team USA home after pool play for the first time in WBC history.
Yes, this Team USA ‒ of Aaron Judge and Kyle Schwarber’s tape-measure power, Bobby Witt Jr.’s all-around brilliance, Paul Skenes’ utter dominance. Yes, the best collection of talent in a half-dozen WBCs.
On paper, they wouldn’t be going home because DeRosa misspoke, or because he rested a handful of so-called regulars. Heck, No. 9 hitter and part-time center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong drove in four of their runs with a pair of homers in an urgent comeback that fell short in the 8-6 loss to Italy. Lineup hot takes are almost worse in the WBC than the regular season, especially with the blue chip depth Team USA enjoys.
No, they’d be going home largely because the club was perhaps one starting pitcher short of unbeatable. Nolan McLean, entering his first full season as a New York Met, was not up to the task of putting the paisans down, leaving with a 3-0 deficit after giving up a pair of rockets to Chicago White Sox catcher Kyle Teel and White Sox farmhand Sam Antonacci.
Rockies right-hander Michael Lorenzen – a former teammate of several Team USA members – threw the ball terrifically. The deficit grew. Perhaps DeRosa could have lifted long reliever Ryan Yarbrough before his outing mushroomed into ‘wear it’ territory, a situation that looked worse when the USA nearly clawed back all of an 8-0 deficit.
The looks on the faces of Team USA as all this unfolded were startling. A mix of astonishment, a sinking feeling that they could, in fact, be eliminated, perhaps doing mathematic machinations as the espresso shots flew in the Italians’ dugout.
Funny thing about ballplayers: Some are thoroughly locked in to what’s happening on a given day. Others don’t know what day it is, nor whether they just took part in a historic Farris-Buehler matchup.
But a lot of that stuff isn’t their job. Their job is to show up and ball. The button-pushing, the logistics, the bigger picture after The Neverending Today – that’s the manager’s job. The surprising thing about DeRosa’s gaffe is that he’s not a major league manager parachuting in from Florida or Arizona.
His lone job, other than gassing up his guests on MLB Network or playing wingman when Rob Manfred’s in a union-bustin’ mood, is managing the WBC team. Look, we all fall victim – present company included – to WBC Brain, misinterpreting pool-play standings and looming tiebreakers.
Yet this is DeRosa’s whole deal. That three teams finishing pool play 3-1 is potentially bad news, and that there was one Team USA game remaining, against an unbeaten team, should have been seared into his brain.
Alas, he verbally punched their ticket, acknowledged at a pregame press conference both that he ‘misspoke’ and also he ‘completely misread the calculations’ regarding his interview that vanished from the league web site but is still available online.
The sequence does little to tamp down the notion that the Americans are a bit less passionate about this event than their rivals. Save for the grit-and-grind, Jim Leyland-led group that won it all in 2017, Team USA has always been Team Taciturn, the staid actors in an event fueled by passion. The guard has come down a little bit in recent events, but a Team USA game won’t be confused for an international party anytime soon.
For that, DeRosa can be thankful. Imagine if he were managing Puerto Rico or the Dominican Republic or Venezuela, and erred in his calculations, and then his team got their butts kicked by an underdog. The noise might be a bit louder than a few hot takes from a handful of vodcasters.
Of course, an Italy win over Mexico makes all this so much Mountain Valley Spring Water under the bridge. Or a Mexico win with a lot of runs on the board. DeRosa will certainly be watching, and will full well know the score.